{"ok":true,"route":"/api/runtime/scientific-seal/status","public_safe":true,"read_only":true,"side_effects_performed":false,"version":"scientific-seal-status-v1","status":"STRUCTURAL_SEAL_READY_EMPIRICAL_PROMOTION_GATED","noWrite":true,"memory_written_by_this_route":false,"graphstate_mutated":false,"claim_promoted_by_this_route":false,"headline":"Native do-calculus and structural causal math prove identification structure, not causal truth.","sealRings":[{"id":"structural_honesty","status":"READY","meaning":"DAG rules, d-separation, backdoor/frontdoor, and do-calculus rule receipts pass golden structural checks."},{"id":"identification_honesty","status":"READY_STRUCTURAL_ONLY","meaning":"KELLY separates P(Y|X) from P(Y|do(X)) and tags identification as a structural claim under stated assumptions."},{"id":"empirical_honesty","status":"GATED_BY_DATA_REFUTATION_SETTLEMENT","meaning":"A structural identification receipt is not causal truth until empirical data, refutation, settlement, and replay support it."},{"id":"governance_honesty","status":"COURT_GATED","meaning":"External y0/DoWhy and native causal math produce candidates; Claim Court and Memory Court decide promotion."},{"id":"calibration_honesty","status":"FORWARD_SETTLEMENT_REQUIRED","meaning":"Forecast skill claims require scored settlements and calibration pressure; they do not prove causal truth by themselves."}],"promotionChain":["observational_data_or_dag","native_structural_identification","do_calculus_rule_receipt","external_y0_or_dowhy_candidate","empirical_estimate_and_refutation","settlement_and_calibration","claim_court_review","memory_court_review","governed_memory_or_graphstate_promotion"],"implementationAudit":[{"id":"phase_1_structural_math","title":"Structural math seal","status":"IMPLEMENTED_AND_HARDENED","evidence":["native_dsep_backdoor_frontdoor_golden_vectors","do_calculus_rule_receipts","large_graph_deferral_not_fail_open","canonical_math_ssot_hash_manifest","release_gate_visible_scientific_seal_status"],"remaining":["cross_repo_brain_math_hash_enforcement"]},{"id":"phase_2_symbolic_external_parity","title":"External symbolic parity","status":"SYMBOLIC_PARITY_COUNTERFACTUAL_TRANSPORT_VISIBLE_PROMOTION_GATED","evidence":["public_y0_proxy_sanitizes_upstream_payload","modal_candidate_lane_is_candidate_only","native_vs_external_disagreement_requires_review","external_causal_runtime_seal_visible","live_y0_golden_graph_parity_route_executes_modal","counterfactual_transport_identifiability_gate_visible","counterfactual_identifiability_receipts_visible","transportability_receipts_visible"],"remaining":[]},{"id":"phase_3_empirical_estimation","title":"Empirical estimation seal","status":"EMPIRICAL_PROMOTION_READY_FOR_GOVERNED_TRUTH_ADAPTER","evidence":["dowhy_and_linearmodels_are_candidate_generators","structural_receipts_do_not_promote_truth","settlement_and_refutation_required_before_ground_truth","real_domain_refutation_receipts_visible","empirical_promotion_readiness_passes"],"remaining":[]},{"id":"phase_4_quasi_experiment","title":"Quasi-experiment seal","status":"QUASI_EXPERIMENT_RECEIPTS_VISIBLE_PROMOTION_GATED","evidence":["claim_court_promotion_chain_names_empirical_closure","no_quasi_experiment_direct_promotion_route","quasi_experiment_receipt_family_visible"],"remaining":[]},{"id":"phase_5_benchmark","title":"Benchmark seal","status":"BENCHMARK_FIXTURE_AND_LIVE_SOURCE_RECEIPTS_READY_PROMOTION_GATED","evidence":["benchmark_failures_do_not_write_memory","scientific_seal_exposes_pending_benchmark_status","csuite_style_known_graph_fixture_receipts","causalbench_style_perturbational_fixture_receipts","causalbn_style_scale_deferral_fixture_receipts","live_external_benchmark_source_receipts","causalbench_dataset_blob_receipts"],"remaining":[],"followups":["weekly_benchmark_trust_score","full_package_scoring_when_runtime_budget_allows"]},{"id":"phase_6_intervention","title":"Intervention seal","status":"OBSERVED_INTERVENTION_VOLUME_READY_COURT_STORAGE_VERIFIED","evidence":["simulated_interventions_are_not_truth","pre_registered_falsifiers_required_before_promotion","ten_observed_intervention_cases_registered","three_domain_intervention_diversity_met","final_claim_court_and_storage_verification_visible","observed_intervention_threshold_met"],"remaining":[]},{"id":"phase_7_durable_truth","title":"Durable truth seal","status":"COURT_REPLAY_STORAGE_CHAIN_VERIFIED_PROMOTION_ELIGIBLE","evidence":["claim_court_before_truth","memory_court_before_graphstate","proof_receipt_and_replay_required_for_durable_claims","proof_storage_static_guards_visible","final_claim_court_review_docket_visible","live_storage_immutability_verified","proof_chain_break_release_gate_enforced","final_claim_court_storage_verified"],"remaining":[]}],"supportStatus":{"route":"/api/runtime/scientific-seal/support","status":"SCIENTIFIC_SEAL_AUDIT_LINES_VISIBLE","large_graph_deferral":"PASS_DEFERRED_NOT_FAIL_OPEN","math_ssot_parity":"CANONICAL_MATH_SSOT_READY_BRAIN_PARITY_PENDING","y0_parity":"DEDICATED_LIVE_Y0_PARITY_ROUTE_AVAILABLE_NATIVE_FALLBACK_READY","y0_disagreement_review":"DEDICATED_Y0_DISAGREEMENT_REVIEW_ROUTE_AVAILABLE","external_runtime_seal":"EXTERNAL_CAUSAL_RUNTIME_NOT_CONFIGURED","empirical_seal":"EMPIRICAL_SEAL_CANDIDATE_LANES_READY_PROMOTION_GATED","counterfactual_transport":"COUNTERFACTUAL_TRANSPORT_RECEIPTS_READY_PROMOTION_GATED","benchmark_intervention":"BENCHMARK_AND_INTERVENTION_SEAL_VISIBLE_PROMOTION_GATED","discovery_unknown_ledger":"DISCOVERY_ENGINE_ACTIVE_GOVERNED_AUTONOMY_READY","discovery_question_generator":"question_generator","discovery_generated_questions":5,"proof_storage_seal":"PROOF_STORAGE_SEAL_LIVE_IMMUTABILITY_VERIFIED_READ_ONLY","nextPatchQueue":[]},"currentProof":{"native_structural_math":true,"golden_vectors_ok":true,"do_calculus_rules_ready":true,"external_candidate_lane_ready":true,"external_runtime_seal_visible":true,"y0_disagreement_review_visible":true,"canonical_math_ssot_visible":true,"discovery_unknown_ledger_visible":true,"discovery_questions_visible":true,"proof_storage_static_guards_visible":true,"direct_promotion_allowed":false,"empirical_truth_claim_allowed":false},"requiredBeforeGroundTruth":["empirical_do_or_observed_intervention_when_available","external_y0_or_dowhy_candidate_when_relevant","refutation_or_falsifier_record","settlement_record","calibration_record","claim_court_approval","memory_court_approval","replay_receipt"],"uiLanguage":{"allowed":"KELLY identified this causal structure under stated assumptions and is waiting for empirical closure before promotion.","forbidden":"KELLY proved this causal effect is true from structure alone."},"boundary":"Scientific seal is a promotion ladder. Structural math can open the door; reality, refutation, settlement, calibration, and courts decide what becomes durable truth.","contentHash":"2b6389812eeb9787c6f3521eb7f8f271d91a194fbceb3a61e071124e49ced31f","public_frontend_proxy":true,"side_effect_class":"read_only_status","side_effect_contract":{"route":"/api/runtime/scientific-seal/status","method":"GET","side_effect_class":"read_only_status","prime_truth_mutation_allowed":false,"memory_write_allowed":false,"graphstate_mutation_allowed":false,"event_ledger_mutation_allowed":false,"provider_mutation_allowed":false},"prime_truth_mutation_allowed":false,"memory_write_allowed":false,"graphstate_mutation_allowed":false,"event_ledger_mutation_allowed":false,"provider_mutation_allowed":false,"proxy_source":"primary_engine_runtime_fallback"}